Jorge Garcia, 39, of Lincoln Park, hugs his wife and two kids before being escorted by ICE agents to be deported to Mexico, on Jan. 15, 2018, at Detroit Metro Airport.
DETROIT — Immigration officials are defending the deportation of Jorge Garcia, a metro Detroit man whose case has sparked national attention since he was removed from the U.S. on Monday.
In a statement, the Detroit office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) said that they had previously “exercised prosecutorial discretion” in allowing him to stay in the U.S. But that discretion ended in November when ICE told him he now had to leave.
Garcia, a married father of two from Lincoln Park, had lived in the U.S. since 1989, brought to the U.S. by undocumented family members. He had struggled for years to become a legal resident, trying various paths with the help of attorneys and working with immigration officials.
Though Garcia faced orders of removal, U.S. officials had allowed him for years to stay. But that changed in November, when he was told by ICE that he would be removed, part of a toughening of immigration enforcement under President Trump.
His deportation on Martin Luther King Jr. Day sparked a national outcry, with a wide range of commentators and officials — both conservative and liberal — calling it an outrageous move. Others defended Garcia’s deportation, saying he didn’t have legal status to remain in the U.S.
In a statement Tuesday night, Detroit ICE spokesman Khaalid Walls said: “As ICE Deputy Director Thomas Homan has made clear, ICE does not exempt classes or categories of removable aliens from potential enforcement. All of those in violation of the immigration laws may be subject to immigration arrest, detention and, if found removable by final order, removal from the United States.”
Walls said that Garcia was “an unlawfully present citizen of Mexico” who “was ordered removed by an immigration judge in June 2006.”
ICE said in its statement that Garcia “appealed his removal in 2008 to the Board of Immigration Appeals, where it was remanded back to the lower court, which subsequently allowed him to voluntarily depart. After he failed to depart within the timeline of the agreement, he became subject to a final order of removal in 2009.
“ICE exercised prosecutorial discretion on multiple prior occasions in Mr. Garcia-Martinez’s case in 2011, 2012 and 2014. In a further exercise of discretion during the this period, Mr. Garcia-Martinez was never detained.”
“On Jan. 15, Mr. Martinez was removed pursuant to the judge’s removal order.”
First reported by the Detroit Free Press, Garcia’s deportation has been widely reported by a number of media outlets and generated criticism from many readers, elected officials, church leaders, and advocacy groups.
Garcia’s family is trying to help get him returned to the U.S., but the process could take at least 10 years, said his wife, Cindy Garcia. He said he’s planning to live for now in the Mexico City area.
Speaking to the Free Press Sunday night on the eve of the deportation, the Garcias said they spent about $125,000 on attorneys and filing fees trying to get Jorge legal status.
Garcia said he was too old to qualify for DACA. He said he has asked ICE if they could delay his Jan. 15 deportation until after Congress passes legislation on DACA that may include people in his age group, but ICE refused.
Follow Niraj Warikoo on Twitter: @nwarikoo
WH: Trump Immigration Laws Will Make US Safer | 1:27
Assistant Attorney General of the National Security Division, Edward O’Callaghan, took questions at Wednesday’s press briefing. He supported President Donald Trump’s immigration reforms saying they will improve security and make the US safer. (Jan. 17)
Hispanic Caucus: ‘Little progress’ on DACA | 1:09
Members of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus and other Democrats met privately in the Capitol with White House Chief of Staff John Kelly. (Jan. 17)
WH: Trump’s Take On Immigration ‘Colorblind’ | 1:50
WH Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders defended President Trump’s use of vulgarity when referring to immigrants from Haiti and African countries last week, calling his policy ‘colorblind’ because it stands for a merit-based immigration system. (Jan. 16)
Graham, Durbin blame White House staff on immigration | 1:52
Senators are blaming President Trump’s staff for the president’s about-face on immigration that appeared to scuttle a compromise deal last week to protect from deportation young people brought to the U.S. as children and living here illegally. (Jan. 16)
Dem. Senators slam Trump meeting remarks | 2:23
WARNING: GRAPHIC LANGUAGE: Democratic Senators Mazie Hirono of Hawaii and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut slammed President Donald Trump for allegedly using vulgar language to describe Haiti and African countries in a meeting last week. (Jan. 16)
Booker to Nielsen: Your silence is complicity | 2:33
Sen. Cory Booker is criticizing the Homeland Security secretary for saying she can’t recall President Trump using vulgarity to describe African countries. And Sen. Lindsey Graham blames Trump’s staff for the president’s about-face on immigration. (Jan. 16)
Trump says he wants immigrants from ‘everywhere’ | 1:18
President Trump says he wants immigrants to come to the U.S. from “everywhere,” despite having said behind closed doors that he’d prefer more immigrants from places such as Norway and Asia rather than parts of Africa. (Jan. 16)
Trump says he’s ‘not a racist’ | 0:55
President Trump is under fire after reportedly referring to Haiti and African countries with a derogatory term.
Republicans urge focus on immigration issue | 2:29
Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Congressman Mario Diaz-Balart of Florida, both Republicans, focused on immigration and DACA when asked about President Trump’s reported comments about African countries and Haiti on Monday. (Jan. 16)
White House: Claims that Trump is racist are ‘outrageous’ | 2:47
White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders says she is confident a budget deal can be reached before a potential government shutdown at midnight Friday night. Sanders also called Democrats’ claims that Trump is a racist “outrageous.” (Jan. 16)
Meet Trump at the middle and protect DREAMers | 2:31
Daniel Garza, President of The LIBRE Initiative, gives his take on why it’s important to deliver a permanent solution to the DREAMer community.
Poll: Most Americans support DACA program | 1:05
Most Americans support maintaining the Deferred Action on Childhood Arrivals program. Veuer’s Maria Mercedes Galuppo (@mariamgaluppo) has more.
White House: No deal reached yet on immigration | 0:49
White House Spokesperson Sarah Huckabee Sanders says despite reports to the contrary, no deal has been reached yet on legislation to protect younger immigrants brought to the country illegally, but she says, “they’re close.” (Jan. 11)
Pelosi scorns ‘five white guys’ on immigration | 2:49
Top House Democrat Nancy Pelosi says an immigration working group is just “five white guys.” Pelosi’s talking about a group of lawmakers that’s blessed by President Trump to find a deal to protect ‘Dreamers’. (Jan. 11)
Donald Trump outlines 4 areas of immigration reform | 0:54
A border wall is still a must-have.
House Democrats Urge Protection for ‘Dreamers’ | 2:10
Democratic lawmakers pressed for protections for nearly 800,000 immigrants who arrived illegally in the U.S. as children. They were joined by so-called ‘Dreamers’ as they spoke to reporters outside the U.S. Capitol. (Jan. 10)
Tucker Carlson on Trump: What was the point of running for President? | 1:18
Fox News host Tucker Carlson sounding off following a surprisingly congenial meeting between President Trump and lawmakers to tackle immigration reform.
A federal Judge has blocked Trump’s plan to end the DACA program | 1:39
A federal judge on Tuesday night temporarily blocked the Trump administration’s decision to end a program protecting young immigrants from deportation.
Trump: Immigration deal should be ‘bill of love’ | 1:37
Pushing for compromise on immigration reform, President Donald Trump urged a bipartisan group of lawmakers gathered at the White House to put “country before party” and negotiate a deal in two phases, first by addressing young immigrants. (Jan. 9)
Trump Administration rules nearly 200,000 Salvadorans must leave | 1:03
The Trump administration will end the relief program that grants TPS to immigrants from El Salvador, leaving nearly 200,000 vulnerable to deportation. Nathan Rousseau Smith (@FantasticMrNate) reports.
Trump talks immigration with GOP Senators | 1:43
President Donald Trump says that so-called chain migration provides “a gateway for terrorism.” He made the comment as he sat down Thursday with Republican senators to talk about immigration. (Jan. 4)
Trump reiterates call for immigration overhaul | 1:50
President Donald Trump is reiterating his call to overhaul the nation’s immigration system in the aftermath of the blast in a New York City subway passageway. (Dec. 12)
Thousands rally in support of DACA | 1:13
‘Defend Our Immigrant Communities’ held a rally on Capitol Hill, with tens of thousands of immigrants, activists, and allies. (Dec. 6)
House GOP members ready to craft DACA fix | 1:44
A broad range of House Republicans said they were ready to work to craft a new legislative fix for young immigrants, known by supporters as Dreamers, before the end of this year.
Congressional Hispanic Caucus blasts Trump on DACA | 1:43
Dem. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi joined the chair of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus to blast President Donald Trump’s newly announced position on DACA and building a border wall. (Oct. 11)
White House releases extensive list of immigration policy demands | 1:18
The White House sent a list of immigration policy demands to Congress that President Trump says must be included in legislation addressing “Dreamers.”
Video provided by Newsy
State Department proposes lowest refugee admission cap ever | 1:04
The Trump administration told Congress it wants to cap the number of refugees admitted to the U.S. at 45,000 during the next fiscal year.
Video provided by Newsy
Homeland Security will soon collect immigrants’ social media info | 1:12
Similar programs have already been tested by both ICE and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
Video provided by Newsy
Trump’s travel ban replaced with ‘tailored travel restrictions’ | 1:47
The new order is based on a Department of Homeland Security review of immigration screening procedures.
Video provided by Newsy
Texas asks court to allow ‘sanctuary cities’ ban | 1:17
With immigrants and their advocates chanting outside, a federal appeals court heard arguments on whether to allow a Texas law against so-called ‘sanctuary cities’ to take effect. (Sept. 22)
New citizens greeted with Trump video | 1:35
Hundreds of immigrants taking the oath as new U.S. citizens Wednesday in Los Angeles were also welcomed with a video message from President Trump. In the video, Trump urges them to teach American values. (Sept. 20)
Here’s what the business world is saying about the repeal of DACA | 1:47
Business leaders have rallied behind DREAMers after President Trump’s decision to repeal DACA.
Sessions urges ‘sanctuary cities’ to reconsider | 1:49
U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions has urged “sanctuary cities” to reconsider their status. Sessions said in a speech in Portland, Oregon that the grants are not an entitlement. (Sept. 19)
Immigrants sue over deportation protection end | 1:09
Six immigrants brought to the United States as children who became teachers, graduate students and a lawyer sued the Trump administration on Monday over its decision to end a program shielding them from deportation. (Sept. 18)
Haitians Blocked at Border Find Home in Mexico | 2:20
Thousands of Haitians have settled in Mexico’s northwest corner after the United States abruptly closed its doors. In Tijuana, Haitians wait tables at restaurants and fill factory jobs, pursuing what’s become their ‘Mexican dream.’ (Sept. 19)
Immigrants Hopeful, Wary Of Talk On DACA Deal | 1:27
With talk in the nation’s capital of a possible deal to salvage a program that protects undocumented immigrants from deportation, some immigrants were watching anxiously and hoping for an outcome that let’s them stay in the U.S. (Sept. 14)
Killing DACA: Why Trump’s decision matters to ‘Dreamers’ | 1:38
We break down what DACA is and what it could mean for thousands of immigrants.
Young immigrants and DACA: AP explains | 1:48
What’s the next step for young immigrants protected from deportation under a program that is being phased out by the Trump administration? AP takes a closer look at the program and those affected by its closure. (Sept. 7)
Trump dismantles DACA protections for immigrants | 2:39
Dealing a huge blow to hundreds of thousands of immigrants, the Trump administration announced it’s phasing out the DACA program and leaving it to Congress to come up with a plan. Dreamers and their supporters said they won’t give up the fight. (Sept. 5)
Stephen miller goes head to head with New York Times reporter | 0:52
Senior White House Adviser Stephen Miller went head to head with a New York Times reporter during Wednesday’s press briefing. Veuer’s Nick Cardona (@nickcardona93) has that story.
Trump wants new limits on legal immigration | 2:01
President Donald unveiled legislation that would place new limits on legal immigration and seek a system based on merit and job skills instead of family connections. (Aug. 2)
CNN journalist questions Trump policy, argument ensues | 1:46
When asked to clarify new Trump’s take on immigration reform, White House adviser Stephen Miller told CNN’s Jim Acosta, a first-generation Cuban American, that his question was “outrageous, insulting, and foolish.”
Mom faces deportation, fears kidnapping | 2:12
Wife and mother of four, Beatriz Casillas, fears being deported to Nuevo Laredo, Mexico. The area is known for having abductors that hold family members for ransom.
Trump describes merit-based immigration system | 1:45
President Donald Trump described for a rally in Youngstown, Ohio a merit-based immigration system that he says he’s working on with two Republican Senators. Trump said it would allow people who have “worked really really hard” into the US.(July 26)
Sessions Singles Out Philly as Sanctuary City | 1:29
Attorney General Jeff Sessions spoke in Philadelphia on Friday, urging the city to reconsider its immigration policies. (July 21)
Powered by WPeMatico